About IIMA

I found very nice introduction about Indian Institute of Ahmedabad in Hindu Business Line. It is also lucidly written by Harish Bhat COO of Titan Industries Ltd, and an alumnus of IIMA. I have posted this here for my collection.

The golden jubilee celebrations of IIM Ahmedabad (IIMA), which are under way this month, give us opportunity to reflect on how great academic institutions, including universities, colleges and schools, transform themselves into powerful and timeless brands. IIMA is an excellent illustration of this phenomenon – it commands universal brand recognition and top-notch brand preference scores amongst all stakeholders, including corporates, government, faculty and students. Like the best brands, it is highly aspirational, and its name evokes widespread awe and admiration.

Brand IIMA has achieved somewhat iconic status. It has a formidable academic reputation, built over half a century. It tops virtually every ranking of Indian business schools today. The Economist’s Survey of Global Business Schools 2009 points out that it is the “toughest in the world to get into”, with over 600 students competing for every seat. Its alumni occupy some of the most coveted positions in Indian industry. Like Harvard and Oxford across the oceans, it has developed its own distinctive culture which sets it apart.

In summary, IIMA is as powerful a brand as some of the best known trademarks in the FMCG, durables, media or financial industries. Admittedly, only a few academic institutions make this transition to becoming big brands in their own right. What triggers this big leap?

At the core of any reputed academic brand is excellence in education. This is derived from a sound and proven syllabus of learning that constantly evolves to meet the demands of the present and future, the ability to attract and retain brilliant and committed faculty passionate about teaching and research, and, of course, excellent physical infrastructure and facilities including laboratories and libraries. These constitute the foundation for any academic institution aspiring to greatness, and IIMA scores high on all of them. Unfortunately, not many universities and colleges in India can claim to possess these essential building blocks, in sharp contrast to their counterparts in the US. This explains why America boasts so many globally respected Ivy League academic brands – Harvard, Wharton, MIT, Stanford, UC Berkeley, University of Chicago, Princeton and so on – while India has so few that make the global cut.

Excellence in education is a necessary but not sufficient condition for a great academic brand. First amongst other factors which count is the heritage of the institution. Great academic brands should have necessarily stood the test of time. Several batches of students should have successfully graduated from its portals. The institution should ideally have been spawned or nurtured by great names in education, arts or the sciences, whose creative vigour, wisdom and vision would have helped shape its canvas. For instance, IIMA has completed 50 immensely successful years, and was also built in collaboration with one of the world’s finest names in management education, the Harvard Business School.

Yet another important factor are the alumni of the institution, who serve as ambassadors of the brand. An academic brand grows greatly in stature when its alumni reach important and well-regarded positions in the world at large. The achievements of its alumni are seen as a strong vindication that the academic institution has excelled in imparting relevant knowledge to its students, in creating champions and winners who serve as role models to future generations of students. Brand IIMA has greatly benefited from distinguished alumni such as C. K. Prahalad, K.V. Kamath, M.S. Banga, Jerry Rao, Raghuram Rajan, Kiran Karnik and Bhaskar Bhat (Managing Director of Titan Industries, where I work), who are greatly admired for their success in the world of business, economics or finance. Alumni who have struck out and made it big in non-mainstream areas – such as danseuse Mallika Sarabhai, cricket commentator Harsha Bhogle and author Chetan Bhagat – have also given the brand an edge and energy which helps break the clutter very well.

Equally important in today’s competitive world are the ratings obtained by the college or university each year, in internationally and nationally reputed compilations. These rankings are a surrogate for the aspirational appeal of the brand, and also an important yardstick by which students decide where they will pursue their future studies. Therefore, they help academic institutions attract the best and brightest students, which further strengthens the brand and protects its future appeal. A top rating also adds greatly to the halo effect surrounding the brand. Undoubtedly, the fact that IIMA obtains the numero uno rank in virtually every rating of Indian business schools adds greatly to its lure.

Every great brand has its legends and mystique, and this is equally relevant to academic institutions. Such legends can spring from many sources – they can emanate from the founders, from professors whose stature and lectures evoke immense admiration and special respect, from researchers and students who win celebrated awards, from famous campus rituals which leave a mark. At IIMA, many such legends have their origin in great faculty – to name just a few (from my time at the Institute), Pradip Khandwalla, Indira Parikh, V.L. Mote, Abhinandan Jain, T.V. Rao, Bakul Dholakia, N. Ravichandran and Samir Barua – the manner in which they taught, guided and tested their classes, and brought out the best in their students. Several years after graduation, many of us who have studied in IIMA continue to discuss these legends, and we will perhaps remain in awe of them for the rest of our lives. That’s what legends are for.

Finally, every great brand rests on its key differentiators, or unique selling points (USPs), which set the brand apart from competition. For academic institutions, such differentiation can arise from areas as diverse as the syllabus, the mode of instruction, undisputed prowess in a specific (sometimes even narrow) functional area, strong links with industry, or even the location of the campus. Brand IIMA has built itself a strong differentiator through its case study method of learning. Lessons in marketing, finance, strategy and the behavioural sciences are taught and learnt not merely through text books and theoretical questions, but through study and discussion of evocative case studies drawn from the real world of business. Despite many contrasting views on how well this works, the institute has remained steadfastly committed to the case study methodology, throughout its existence. This is certainly one of the key reasons why brand IIMA has such distinctive appeal today.

In conclusion, students of marketing as well as aspiring builders of academic institutions would do well to remember one of the fundamental tenets of building great brands – you have to fulfil all key points of parity in your category (such as an excellent academic reputation, and very good physical infrastructure) and also build important points of differentiation (such as a distinctive method of instruction, or heritage and legend). These make all the difference between the many mediocre colleges and schools we see all around us, and the few truly great academic brands.

Original article can be found here.


2 thoughts on “About IIMA

  1. This is an interesting article by Harish who was my classmate as well as dorm mate at IIM Ahmedabad. While there is no doubt that IIMA is a great institution, I think Harish has gone a little over board in his praise of our alma mater.

    In all honesty, I can say that while there were great Professors at IIMA, there were quite a few terrible ones too. I had to go to Columbia University in New York to learn modern quantitative finance theory (from Indian professors there) because the finance faculty at IIMA was simply not good during my time. The quantitative methods and computer science faculty was very good though.

    Also, while IIMA has a large and well designed campus it had very poor medical facilities on the campus for such a significant population. One of the boys a year junior to me and Harish actually died as a result of a soccer match accident which I witnessed myself. The availability of better medical facilities at the campus and then at the civil hospital in Ahmedabad could have saved our friend’s life.

    Amongst other things, IIMA perpetuated a rat race for grades in the name of academic excellence that was not healthy. The students of IIMA were brilliant at getting grades but terible when it came to team work. In fact, even after graduating and working in the cororate worked, IIMA alumni are NOT known to help each other because they were wired to compete and not collaborate.

    So while I am very grateful to IIMA and think it is overall a terrific school I disagree with Harish Bhat’s excessively glowing praise about IIMA. It would have been better if he had a written a more factual and more balanced article.

    1. Hi Rajat,

      Thanks for your valuable notes. I am aware of few things that you mentioned. IIMA is admired because of brilliance of students who get into this consistently top b-school. It would me much better, if teachers help students to co-ordinate and collaborate through group case study/project methodologies. Students few times forget ‘inter-dependence is much valued principle than independent’. but, it is actually because of rat race to be ahead of everyone else. Collaboration would have helped to go few more steps towards research in management.
      Any way. Thanks again for sharing your thoughts 🙂

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s